The pathologist who examined the body of the Camden Ripper's first victim assumed she died of a heart attack, a hearing was told on Monday. I will accept this as the medical cause of her death, so there really is no other conclusion than to conclude this inquiry by recording a verdict that she died as a result of natural causes.. Then he drags her to a bath and tries to drown her. Neighbour June Gentleman, points the police towards Hardy. The GMC had wanted the panel to consider Dr Patels work in the case of Sally White, a prostitute murdered in 2002 by Anthony Hardy, the serial killer known as the Camden Ripper. As the pathologist who wrongly concluded a murder victim died of natural causes is suspended, the New Journals RICHARD OSLEY looks back on the case he has followed since the inquest into Sally Whites death in 2002. [20] Investigators also asked for a woman named Carmen or Carmel to come forward as they believed she had information on the murder, saying she was apparently a friend of Parker and came from the Hounslow or Isleworth area. "It is just not right," said Jackie Valad. After being caught he was tried and jailed for life after pleading guilty to all three murders, despite Dr Patels findings. As Ms Valads mother Jackie told her local newspaper in Nottingham, last year: It ruined my life. Dr Freddy Patel, who has conducted post mortems on hundreds of Camden residents, was subject to a private GMC review last week. We are unable to comment on the specifics of any ongoing cases to avoid prejudicing hearings. by CHARLOTTE CHAMBERS. In November 2003, he was sentenced to three life terms for three murders, but police believe he may have been responsible for up to five more. Published: 09 September, 2010 What would the playwright have made of the murders of Anthony Hardy? That has never happened. This pattern of evading justice would become a distinguishing feature of Hardys horrific crimes. Murdaugh is heckled as he leaves court, Ken Bruce finishes his 30-year tenure as host of BBC Radio 2, Ukrainian soldier takes out five tanks with Javelin missiles, Family of a 10-month-old baby filmed vaping open up, Missing hiker buried under snow forces arm out to wave to helicopter, Hershey's Canada releases HER for SHE bars featuring a trans activist, Moment teenager crashes into back of lorry after 100mph police race. What case was Colin Stagg the suspect in? It follows the panels investigation into three cases dating from 2003 to 2005. and although they took the very rare step of requesting a second autopsy be conducted, Dr Freddy Patel returned with the same conclusion - "heart failure". Dr Freddy Patel, 63, was told on Friday that the case will not be added to a General Medical Council (GMC) hearing currently investigating four other post-mortems he conducted. A priceless chance was lost when Sally White, now identified as Hardys first known victim, was discovered dead in his back room nearly a year before the deaths of Ms Valad and Ms MacClennan, two women who worked as prostitutes. 1982, Hardy arrested for trying to drown his wife, but charges dropped. Maybe Priestleys Inspector Goole might have wanted to have probed beyond the pathologists inadequate work. Dr Freddy Patel, who had been on a government register of accredited pathologists, was suspended on June 2 He stated then that his current job was as a "Home Office South Eastern Group Practice 20042009" when the dates should have stated 2004-2006. The killer returned to his flat and later in 2002 killed prostitutes Liz Valad and Bridgette MacClennan, chopping up their bodies and throwing them out in black bags. The panel also found proved allegations he did not consider the presence and location of blood staining on the deceased's clothing and bedding, plus the presence of a warm bucket of water next to her body. It must have been a puzzling conclusion to at least 10, 20, maybe 30 or more people who had either been at the crime scene or dealt with Hardy afterwards, people with close knowledge of the case. The pathologist has also been found guilty of dishonesty by providing the GMC with a false CV in 2009. [4] He lived in various hostels in London, picking up convictions for theft[6] and being drunk and disorderly. The judge passes a sentence of life imprisonment. Test yourself with this Cockney Rhyming Slang quiz. But there are nagging what ifs and lasting concerns over whether those two women, Liz Valad, 29, and Bridgette MacClennan, 34, whose heads and hands were never found, might still be alive today if Hardy had been trapped earlier. It has taken nine years and other high-profile cases, notably the death of newspaper seller Ian Tomlinson at the G20 protests, which Dr Patel worked on, for the General Medical Council to reach this stage in its investigation into Dr Patels conclusions. The honeytrap plot that left father-of-six dead: Moment two women lead victim into his flat to seduce him 'Sonic boom' is heard across central England as 'ground shakes' and houses are rocked. Patel was suspended for three months in September last year after a panel found he had carried out three "irresponsible" postmortems, two of which amounted to misconduct. THERE is a touch of An Inspector Calls about the dark tragedies which unfolded on the College Place estate nearly a decade ago. A number of the other allegations however, were found to be not proved. A pathologist was today found guilty of serious misconduct over his post mortem examination reports into the death of a victim of so-called "Camden Ripper" Anthony Hardy. We had done a thorough dissection of the neck and mouth. Dr Patel denies the misconduct charges and insists he was not criticised over the Hardy case. So to that extent there isnt a case for us to investigate. Children drinking PINTS and the King riding in a 14-wheel golden HGV - this is Kate and Prince William 'are keen' for Prince George to have official role in King Charles' coronation - but Royally hard work! At a full public inquiry, Dr Patel would not have been the only one answering questions, such as those he faced during his GMC case. I get paid to investigate unexplained deaths, suspicious deaths not deaths by natural causes. Ripper Anthony Hardy subsequently went on to kill another two prostitutes, Brigitte MacClellan and Elizabeth Valad whose dismembered bodies were found in a dustbin. [25] After Hardy was imprisoned, British rap artist Plan B released his song Suzanne, dubbing Hardy as the 'Camden Ripper' and describing the murder of a fictional prostitute named Suzanne Smith. [14] In May 2010, a High Court judge decided that Hardy should never be released from prison, placing him on the list of whole life tariff prisoners. Updated 23:46, 31 MAR 2011. Hardy had got away with murder and was free to kill again, but the worries and doubts led nobody to formally look again at Ms Whites death. Dec 2002 The dismembered body parts of Bridgette MacClennan and Elizabeth Valad are discovered, Dec 2002 Police find Elizabeth Valads torso in Hardys London flat, Jan 2003 Police arrest Hardy at Great Ormond Street hospital in London, Nov 2003 Hardys trial begins. The panel also gave its findings on each specific aspect of Dr Patel's conduct in relation to whether it was irresponsible, not to standard and liable to bring the profession into disrepute. During an interview another health worker said: I remember a number of reactions. Islington Tribune Dr Andrew Reid, the coroner at St Pancras Coroners Court in Somers Town, said: We have reviewed Dr Patels position in the light of the outcome of the hearing, and subject to any future hearings. It found his work was not of the standard expected of a competent forensic pathologist and liable to bring the medical profession into disrepute.. Welcome to the Coronation! Design by. Published: 22 July, 2010 Charges are later dropped 1986 The marriage breaks down and Hardy returns to London alone Dr Freddy Patel, who has been criticised for his part in the investigation into the death of Ian Tomlinson during the G20 protests, has been facing a General Medical Council hearing over his. He was eventually charged with the murders of both MacClennan and Valad, and of White, the woman whose death had originally been put down to natural causes. [15] However, one of the murders Hardy was originally linked to, that of London sex worker Paula Fields whose body was dumped in the Thames in 2001, was in fact solved in 2011 when John Sweeney was convicted of her murder. Photograph: Fiona Hanson/PA, suspended from the register for three months last September. It found his work was not of the standard expected of a competent forensic pathologist and liable to bring the medical profession into disrepute.. The only investigation that did take place unfolded behind closed doors. Charges are later dropped, 1986 The marriage breaks down and Hardy returns to London alone, 1995 Hardy is sent to a psychiatrist hospital, 1998 Hardy is arrested for an assault on a prostitute. Hardy replies no comment. When an application for a public inquiry reached the Royal Courts of Justice in 2005, brought in the name of Liz Valads daughter, Soraya, Mr Justice Bennett ruled that the government had met its obligations by holding the health authoritys independent review into the mental healthcare received by Hardy. He also changes his plea to guilty to the murders of Elizabeth and Bridgette.The court hears from prosecutors and police that Hardy would lure the women to his flat for sex. Now, Dr Patel's case has been resolved at the GMC, the Camden Ripper files may never be reopened again. Prosecutors at his trial would later say his motive for murder was to take pornographic pictures of his victims after he had indulged in a sado-masochistic sex ritual with them. This uncovers blood stains all over Hardys home, including in the bathroom and marks made when he dragged the bodies to the dismemberment room.Other finds would include the tolls used for dismemberment, pornographic films and masks used to in photos to cover the faces of the dead women.CCTV footage from the local area shows Hardy dumping bin bags near in Plender Street in Camden, on the site where police would later discover human remains. A pathologist, Dr Freddy Patel, reported she had died from natural causes and as a result police, despite knowing the full peculiar details of how she was found, said they had little choice but . Its stomach-turning material. Copyright 2023 Looking back, it is amazing to think it was all over in 15 minutes. In 2010, Mr Justice Keith rules that Hardy will join an elite group of the countrys most dangerous criminals for whom life means life. Is that, Mr Hardy, is the dead lady, the corpse which we found in your bedroom? asks the veteran detective. Last week, pathologist Dr Freddy Patel was suspended for concluding that Ms White had died from natural causes and not considering other possibilities. Inside Prince Harry's finances from when he met Meghan Markle to landing 100M with Netflix and book Spare 'Why the last-minute delay?' A detective sergeant attached to the serious crime group wrote simply: Police have conducted an investigation and, although it is obvious that Mr Hardy is in need of psychiatric help, there is no evidence to suggest he was responsible for the death of Sally White. Police film inside Hardys squalid flat revealing the contents and a grim insight into Hardy and his thirst for violence and sex: pornographic films, satanic dubbings on the walls, tools of torture and blood stains. cze 21, 2022 | aritzia check in store availability | wife share in husband property after death in islam | aritzia check in store availability | wife share in husband property after death in islam He pleaded guilty at the Old Bailey in November 2003 to killing three women at his council flat in Camden Town. With effect from Friday, September 3 2010 Dr Patel is no longer instructed, requested or directed to perform autopsies under The Coroners Act 1988 by HM Coroner for The Inner North District of Greater London (Camden, Hackney, Islington and Tower Hamlets).. In a third report, after he was again asked to expand on asphyxia, Patel concluded: "There were no signs of asphyxia and death was due to natural causes. A spokeswoman for the GMC said: We acknowledge the comments made by the panel. Dr Patel had judged that Sallys death in Hardys Camden Town council flat had been due to natural causes. He was told he had brought the profession. [16][18] Possible links between Hardy and the Parker case were noted in the press as soon as he was apprehended in January 2003, with detectives saying that "he is a suspect for the unsolved murders of any women whose bodies have been cut up and dumped". Hardy said an alcohol-induced blackout meant he could not recall how Ms Whites body ended up in his room. 2nd July 2009 The pathologist who ruled one of Camden Ripper serial killer Anthony Hardy's victims died of natural causes has been suspended by the pathologists' monitoring board following a second controversy, the New Journal can reveal. The only investigation that did take place unfolded behind closed doors. Presumably, the police officers, the coroner of the day, the mental health services and even the council, as his landlord aware of Hardys low-level nuisance behaviour on the estate, would have been called to give evidence in an open forum. Lawal set for Elite test after latest win, Road less travelled in Women Behind the Wheel, New Journal Enterprises 2023. Asked when and in what manner he destroyed his notes on Ms Whites post-mortem, he said: Around that period [2007-8] I would take stock of all my reports and the ones out of date would be shredded. Now, Dr Patels case has been resolved at the GMC, the Camden Ripper files may never be reopened again. CPAC: Who will Republicans support in presidential race? Hardy marries his university sweetheart, Judith Dwight in 1972 and has four children. Resolved: Release in which this issue/RFE has been resolved. Patel was accused of irresponsible conduct and a further charge of dishonesty over a CV entry. There was no mention of the presence of the bucket of warm water in the room where Sally Whites body was found, which proved Mr Hardy was lying when he denied any knowledge of her presence in his flat. Presumably, the police officers, the coroner of the day, the mental health services and even the council, as his landlord aware of Hardys low-level nuisance behaviour on the estate, would have been called to give evidence in an open forum. Simon Jackson QC, the GMCs barrister, had argued that it was in the public interest that the case be adjudicated on. Hardy, despite a history of mental illness, a personality disorder and schizophrenia, was said to have been bad, not mad at the time of his killings. With an indication of the violence to come, Hardy freezes a bottle of water and clubs his wife around the head with it while she sleeps. Design by. Dr Patel said he destroyed his paperwork because it was not brought to my attention there was still concern about my cause of death. The coroner had no other way of knowing these things. Dr Freddy Patel, who has been criticised for his part in the investigation into the death of Ian Tomlinson during the G20 protests, has been facing a General Medical Council hearing over his examinations of 31-year-old prostitute Sally White. This discouraged a police investigation that might have saved two later victims of Hardy, an earlier hearing was told. Dr Freddy Patel is accused of "irresponsible" conduct in connection with post-mortem examination reports in 2002 into the death of 31-year-old prostitute Sally White, the first victim of Anthony . Of course, the man who became known as the Camden Ripper shoulders the responsibility. I never got over it. The dismembered remains of the two other victims were found in December that year in bin bags near his home in north London. By. Dr Patel had told an earlier inquest that she had died from heart problems. Evidence was to come closer to home, when police find a square shaped package covered in black bin bags in Hardys flat. A General Medical Council . The killer returned to his flat and later in 2002 killed prostitutes Liz Valad and Bridgette MacClennan, chopping up their bodies and throwing them out in black bags. A spokesperson for Patel said he intended to consider the panel's decision carefully with his advisers. The panel said it did not want to speculate on what might have happened if Dr Chan had been briefed differently but its report added: The effect of the police statement was to close off any further inquiry by the coroner It conveyed a misleading and unduly reassuring impression about the circumstances., The Metropolitan Police did answer this criticism, insisting the detectives involved were never asked to attend the inquest, although it conceded: Regrettably, for an unascertainable reason, the letter sent to the coroner for the purposes of releasing Sally Whites body was tendered in evidence and the wider concerns of the investigative team were not fully brought before the coroner.. [CDATA[// >